{"study":{"slug":"buy-online-study","title":"When somebody searches to buy a product, who owns the top three?","url":"https://justmarket.me/research/buy-online-study","headline":"Across 90 product searches in 30 categories, walking the search term from a broad category down to a long-tail product raised the marketplace share of the top three organic results from 19.3% to 48.3% and cut the share held by brands and specialist shops from 44.3% to 23.6% — the opposite of the direction predicted before measuring, and the opposite of what \"go long-tail\" advice assumes.","published":"2026-08-13","measuredFrom":"2026-08-13","measuredTo":"2026-08-13"},"method":["90 live searches on 2026-08-13: 30 consumer product categories across 10 retail sectors, each searched at three levels of term specificity, first three organic results only.","The category list, the three search terms per category, the query template, both classification schemes, the publication floors and six numbered predictions were committed before the first search ran.","Every result slot is classified on two independent axes — who controls the domain, and what kind of page it is — from the title and the URL alone.","The query template never changes: the word \"buy\", the term, the word \"online\". Only the specificity of the term varies, which is what makes the three rungs comparable.","Titles and URLs only: no page was fetched, and organic results only — no Shopping tab, no product carousel, no sponsored listings, no personalisation.","5 of 270 slots were low confidence on seller type and 0 on page type; each is excluded from figures on that axis and reported as a count."],"licence":{"name":"Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International","short":"CC BY 4.0","url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","summary":"Use these figures anywhere, including commercially, including modified, as long as JustMarket.Me is credited and the method and limits travel with the numbers."},"citation":"Maulidah, D. Z. (2026). When somebody searches to buy a product, who owns the top three?. JustMarket.Me. https://justmarket.me/research/buy-online-study","attribution":"JustMarket.Me — https://justmarket.me/research/buy-online-study","figures":{"slug":"buy-online-study","measuredOn":"2026-08-13","measuredTo":"2026-08-13","template":"buy <term> online","categoriesCount":30,"sectorsCount":10,"rungsCount":3,"queriesCount":90,"slotsTotal":270,"hostsDistinct":113,"lowConfSeller":5,"lowConfSellerPct":1.9,"lowConfPage":0,"lowConfPagePct":0,"sellerBase":265,"pageBase":270,"crossBase":265,"localeNonUs":9,"localeNonUsPct":3.3,"overall":{"seller":{"marketplace":{"n":85,"pct":32.1},"massRetailer":{"n":91,"pct":34.3},"specialistRetailer":{"n":42,"pct":15.8},"brandDirect":{"n":41,"pct":15.5},"publisher":{"n":5,"pct":1.9},"community":{"n":1,"pct":0.4},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"pageType":{"product":{"n":43,"pct":15.9},"category":{"n":203,"pct":75.2},"article":{"n":9,"pct":3.3},"homepage":{"n":14,"pct":5.2},"thread":{"n":1,"pct":0.4},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"base":265,"ownable":{"n":83,"pct":31.3},"rentable":{"n":85,"pct":32.1},"unreachable":{"n":97,"pct":36.6}},"byRung":{"S1":{"slotsMeasured":90,"sellerBase":88,"pageBase":90,"seller":{"marketplace":{"n":17,"pct":19.3},"massRetailer":{"n":30,"pct":34.1},"specialistRetailer":{"n":24,"pct":27.3},"brandDirect":{"n":15,"pct":17},"publisher":{"n":2,"pct":2.3},"community":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"pageType":{"product":{"n":0,"pct":0},"category":{"n":76,"pct":84.4},"article":{"n":3,"pct":3.3},"homepage":{"n":11,"pct":12.2},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"base":88,"ownable":{"n":39,"pct":44.3},"rentable":{"n":17,"pct":19.3},"unreachable":{"n":32,"pct":36.4}},"S2":{"slotsMeasured":90,"sellerBase":88,"pageBase":90,"seller":{"marketplace":{"n":25,"pct":28.4},"massRetailer":{"n":38,"pct":43.2},"specialistRetailer":{"n":9,"pct":10.2},"brandDirect":{"n":14,"pct":15.9},"publisher":{"n":2,"pct":2.3},"community":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"pageType":{"product":{"n":4,"pct":4.4},"category":{"n":82,"pct":91.1},"article":{"n":2,"pct":2.2},"homepage":{"n":2,"pct":2.2},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"base":88,"ownable":{"n":23,"pct":26.1},"rentable":{"n":25,"pct":28.4},"unreachable":{"n":40,"pct":45.5}},"S3":{"slotsMeasured":90,"sellerBase":89,"pageBase":90,"seller":{"marketplace":{"n":43,"pct":48.3},"massRetailer":{"n":23,"pct":25.8},"specialistRetailer":{"n":9,"pct":10.1},"brandDirect":{"n":12,"pct":13.5},"publisher":{"n":1,"pct":1.1},"community":{"n":1,"pct":1.1},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"pageType":{"product":{"n":39,"pct":43.3},"category":{"n":45,"pct":50},"article":{"n":4,"pct":4.4},"homepage":{"n":1,"pct":1.1},"thread":{"n":1,"pct":1.1},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"base":89,"ownable":{"n":21,"pct":23.6},"rentable":{"n":43,"pct":48.3},"unreachable":{"n":25,"pct":28.1}}},"ladder":{"marketplaceS1":19.3,"marketplaceS2":28.4,"marketplaceS3":48.3,"marketplaceS1toS3":29,"ownableS1":44.3,"ownableS2":26.1,"ownableS3":23.6,"ownableS1toS3":-20.7,"unreachableS1":36.4,"unreachableS3":28.1,"marketplaceRisePts":29,"ownableFallPts":20.7,"marketplaceS3OverS1":2.5,"productPageS1":0,"productPageS3":43.3,"productPageS1n":0,"productPageS3n":39},"queriesZeroOwnable":{"S1":6,"S2":19,"S3":17,"all":42,"allBase":90},"queriesAllOwnable":10,"queriesAllMarketplace":7,"catsZeroOwnableS1":6,"topHosts":[{"host":"amazon.com","n":65,"pct":24.1},{"host":"walmart.com","n":36,"pct":13.3},{"host":"bestbuy.com","n":15,"pct":5.6},{"host":"ebay.com","n":13,"pct":4.8},{"host":"homedepot.com","n":11,"pct":4.1},{"host":"target.com","n":4,"pct":1.5},{"host":"instacart.com","n":3,"pct":1.1},{"host":"orangewoodguitars.com","n":3,"pct":1.1},{"host":"sleepez.com","n":3,"pct":1.1},{"host":"tractorsupply.com","n":3,"pct":1.1}],"amazon":{"n":65,"pct":24.1},"walmart":{"n":36,"pct":13.3},"amazonS1":{"n":14,"pct":15.6},"amazonS3":{"n":33,"pct":36.7},"top2Concentration":{"n":101,"pct":37.4},"cross":{"marketplace":{"product":{"n":23,"pct":8.7},"category":{"n":62,"pct":23.4},"article":{"n":0,"pct":0},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"massRetailer":{"product":{"n":9,"pct":3.4},"category":{"n":82,"pct":30.9},"article":{"n":0,"pct":0},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"specialistRetailer":{"product":{"n":3,"pct":1.1},"category":{"n":29,"pct":10.9},"article":{"n":2,"pct":0.8},"homepage":{"n":8,"pct":3},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"brandDirect":{"product":{"n":6,"pct":2.3},"category":{"n":27,"pct":10.2},"article":{"n":2,"pct":0.8},"homepage":{"n":6,"pct":2.3},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"publisher":{"product":{"n":0,"pct":0},"category":{"n":0,"pct":0},"article":{"n":5,"pct":1.9},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"community":{"product":{"n":0,"pct":0},"category":{"n":0,"pct":0},"article":{"n":0,"pct":0},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":1,"pct":0.4},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"other":{"product":{"n":0,"pct":0},"category":{"n":0,"pct":0},"article":{"n":0,"pct":0},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}}},"pageMixOwnable":{"base":83,"product":{"n":9,"pct":10.8},"category":{"n":56,"pct":67.5},"article":{"n":4,"pct":4.8},"homepage":{"n":14,"pct":16.9},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"pageMixMarketplace":{"base":85,"product":{"n":23,"pct":27.1},"category":{"n":62,"pct":72.9},"article":{"n":0,"pct":0},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"pageMixMassRetailer":{"base":91,"product":{"n":9,"pct":9.9},"category":{"n":82,"pct":90.1},"article":{"n":0,"pct":0},"homepage":{"n":0,"pct":0},"thread":{"n":0,"pct":0},"other":{"n":0,"pct":0}},"ladderCollapse":{"s3Base":90,"s3RepeatingS1":0,"s3RepeatPct":0,"s2s3Base":180,"s2s3RepeatingS1":0,"s2s3RepeatPct":0,"threshold":40,"collapsed":false},"sectors":[{"sector":"apparel-accessories","base":25,"ownablePct":52,"marketplacePct":36},{"sector":"outdoor-sport","base":26,"ownablePct":46.2,"marketplacePct":30.8},{"sector":"baby-kids-office","base":27,"ownablePct":44.4,"marketplacePct":33.3},{"sector":"hobby-craft-music","base":27,"ownablePct":37,"marketplacePct":33.3},{"sector":"tools-garden-auto","base":26,"ownablePct":30.8,"marketplacePct":26.9},{"sector":"home-furniture","base":27,"ownablePct":29.6,"marketplacePct":18.5},{"sector":"pet-supplies","base":26,"ownablePct":23.1,"marketplacePct":42.3},{"sector":"electronics-audio","base":27,"ownablePct":18.5,"marketplacePct":29.6},{"sector":"beauty-personal-care","base":27,"ownablePct":18.5,"marketplacePct":40.7},{"sector":"kitchen","base":27,"ownablePct":14.8,"marketplacePct":29.6}],"sectorTop":{"sector":"apparel-accessories","base":25,"ownablePct":52,"marketplacePct":36},"sectorBottom":{"sector":"kitchen","base":27,"ownablePct":14.8,"marketplacePct":29.6},"predictions":[{"id":"P1","claim":"Marketplaces hold at least 25% of all classified slots.","threshold":"≥25%","observed":"32.1%","held":true},{"id":"P2","claim":"Marketplace share falls from S1 to S3 by at least 5 points.","threshold":"fall ≥5 pts","observed":"+29 pts","held":false},{"id":"P3","claim":"Ownable is under 40% of S1 slots.","threshold":"<40%","observed":"44.3%","held":false},{"id":"P4","claim":"Ownable rises from S1 to S3 by at least 8 points.","threshold":"rise ≥8 pts","observed":"-20.7 pts","held":false},{"id":"P5","claim":"Publisher plus community is over 15% of S3 slots.","threshold":">15%","observed":"2.2%","held":false},{"id":"P6","claim":"At least 10 of 30 categories return zero ownable slots on their S1 query.","threshold":"≥10 of 30","observed":"6 of 30","held":false}],"predictionsHeld":1,"predictionsCount":6,"gates":[{"id":"G1","name":"Categories complete across all three rungs","floor":"≥24 of 30","observed":"30 of 30","passed":true},{"id":"G2","name":"Queries measured","floor":"≥72","observed":"90","passed":true},{"id":"G3","name":"Slots measured","floor":"≥216","observed":"270","passed":true},{"id":"G4","name":"Low confidence on seller type","floor":"≤15%","observed":"1.9%","passed":true},{"id":"G5","name":"Low confidence on page type","floor":"≤15%","observed":"0%","passed":true},{"id":"G6","name":"Ladder did not collapse (S3 URLs repeating S1)","floor":"≤40%","observed":"0%","passed":true}],"gatesPassed":6,"gatesCount":6,"pubCommS3":{"n":2,"pct":2.2,"base":89}}}